What are the downsides of a Bitcoin reserve? As Bitcoin continues its rollercoaster ride in financial markets, discussions surrounding its role in national economies have intensified. The idea of states or central banks holding Bitcoin reserves has gained traction, particularly in political and economic circles advocating for financial sovereignty and diversification. But is Bitcoin a viable reserve asset, or does it pose more risks than rewards?
A recent discussion featuring Dr. Jürgen Schaaf, advisor at the European Central Bank (ECB), sheds light on the fundamental concerns surrounding Bitcoin’s potential role as a national reserve. Speaking on the BFRR podcast, Schaaf outlined his skepticism, citing Bitcoin’s volatility, questionable utility, and concerns over its fundamental value.
What are the downsides of a Bitcoin reserve?
Schaaf argues that Bitcoin has not lived up to its original promise as a decentralized payment system. The cryptocurrency, he asserts, remains inefficient for retail transactions due to its slow processing speeds, high transaction costs, and the volatility of its value. While second-layer solutions such as the Lightning Network attempt to address some of these issues, according to Schaaf, they compromise Bitcoin’s security and decentralization—two of its key selling points.
Bitcoin’s price fluctuations, often driven by speculative market movements rather than inherent economic value, make it an unsuitable candidate for national reserves, Schaaf further elaborates. Unlike traditional financial assets such as government bonds or foreign exchange reserves, Bitcoin does not generate interest, dividends, or cash flow, rendering its valuation purely speculative, he argues.
Another key concern is liquidity. Despite Bitcoin’s large market capitalization, a significant portion of holdings remain concentrated in a small number of wallets, reducing the free-floating liquidity available for major institutional transactions. Governments looking to acquire or liquidate large Bitcoin holdings could face significant market disruptions.
The Gold Comparison: A Flawed Analogy?
Bitcoin proponents often liken the digital asset to gold, which has historically played a central role in monetary reserves. However, Schaaf challenges this comparison. Gold has had thousands of years to establish its legitimacy as a store of value and has practical industrial uses in electronics, medicine, and aerospace. Bitcoin, by contrast, lacks any alternative utility beyond speculation.
Additionally, while gold’s supply remains finite due to physical constraints, Bitcoin’s supposed scarcity is a matter of software governance. In theory, superior digital assets could emerge, challenging Bitcoin’s dominance and rendering its value uncertain in the long term.
The Political Dimension of Bitcoin Reserves
The recent debate over Bitcoin reserves has also been fueled by political considerations. U.S. President Donald Trump’s recent statements on integrating Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies into national policy have stirred speculation about whether the U.S. government might consider holding Bitcoin reserves. Meanwhile, countries like El Salvador have embraced Bitcoin as legal tender, albeit with mixed economic results.
Schaaf acknowledges that some countries, particularly those seeking to reduce dependency on the U.S. dollar, may turn to alternative assets. However, he warns that Bitcoin’s volatility and regulatory uncertainties make it a precarious choice compared to established reserve assets like gold or government bonds.
Schaaf remains sceptical
While Bitcoin remains an intriguing financial innovation, its suitability as a reserve asset remains highly contentious. Schaaf’s analysis suggests that Bitcoin’s speculative nature, lack of inherent economic utility, and liquidity concerns make it an unfit candidate for national reserves. For now, while political figures and crypto enthusiasts continue to champion its potential, financial institutions and central banks remain largely skeptical, wary of turning to an asset that behaves more like a high-risk investment than a stable store of value.
After two comprehensive episodes on Bitcoin reserves—examining both the supportive and critical viewpoints—stay tuned for an upcoming episode where the BFRR team will thoughtfully reflect on these discussions and share their own perspective on this both controversial and timely topic.
Bitcoin, Fiat & Rock’n’Roll Website
Bitcoin, Fiat & Rock’n’Roll Telegram Channel
Previous episode with Frank Schäffler on Bitcoin Reserves
Paper Schaaf & Bindseil: The distributional consequences of Bitcoin
[BFRR Episode: ](Bitcoin-Papier der EZB: Zerstört Bitcoin die Demokratie](https://www.bfrr.de/bitcoin-kritik-in-paper-der-ezb/)
Relai*: Buy Bitcoin with Relai – you can do a one-time purchase or savings plan: Click here. Use the referral code „ROCK“ to reduce transaction fees by 0.1% while supporting Bitcoin, Fiat & Rock’n’Roll.
Value4Value Podcast Streaming: Support our podcast by listening to our episodes on the Fountain Podcast App. This way, if you wish, you can support us „Value4Value“ while listening to the podcast. You can find us on the Fountain Podcast App here: Click here
Digital Euro Conference Partnership: BFRR partners with the Digital Euro Conference 2025 taking place on March 27 in Frankfurt. DEC25 brings together leading voices shaping the financial landscape, covering topics around retail and wholesale CBDCs, stablecoins, and tokenized money in general. As an official event partner, BFRR gives away one free ticket for physical participation in Frankfurt. If you are interested, please write us an email to info@bfrr.de by January 31st. If you are not the “lucky winner”, you get 20% off the ticket prices with the code “BFRR20”. To buy your ticket go to the official website Click here and insert the code “BFRR20”.
Disclaimer: The content of this podcast reflects the private opinions of the hosts, serves exclusively for general information purposes and does not constitute investment advice. Always remember: Do your own research – inform yourself before making any investment decisions, such as buying Bitcoin. First try to understand what Bitcoin is and how to store it. This podcast does not provide financial advice. Note that the co-hosts might be invested in crypto assets. Read more on our website: Click here
All links marked with „*“ are affiliate links. If you use these links for purchase, the podcast receives a small share of the revenue without any additional costs to you. On the contrary, affiliate links often include discount promotions, so you can even save money. We would appreciate it if you use these links to support us. Thank you very much!